top of page

Boundary-less Battleground: West Indian Cricket's Identity Crisis

"We were more than just cricketers; we were representing a movement, a fight against oppression and inequality.”– Michael “Whispering Death” Holding.

The West Indies Tour of England 1976 marked a defining moment in cricket history. At a time when the world was plagued by widespread racism, Tony Greig, the captain of the English cricket team, made a fiery statement, “I will make them (West Indies) grovel in front of England.” Leading the West Indies team was their indomitable commander, Clive Lloyd, a colossal figure whose leadership was crucial to their victory. United in their resolve to overcome adversity, the team unleashed a devastating pace assault that left the English batsmen struggling for their very survival. Michael Holding's lightning-fast speed, Andy Roberts' unflinching precision, Joel ‘Big Bird’ Garner's towering presence, and Colin ‘Smiling Assassin’ Croft's unbridled aggression comprised a quartet of unparalleled bowling prowess. With each delivery, they exemplified the fierce and unyielding West Indian character. The series was a dramatic display of their talent, strength, and intimidation, propelling the West Indies to a decisive 3-0 series victory.


Tony Grieg after the test match, the bowlers showed no mercy, umpires had to request them not to bowl to the body.


This was no ordinary victory. Little did Greig know that his ill-advised comment would ignite a fire within the West Indian players, which burned brightly for 20 golden years of West Indian world dominance. Historian Hilary Beckles writes that West Indies cricket “was born, raised, and socialised within the fiery cauldron of colonial oppression and social protest. In its mature form, it is essentially an ideological and politicised species and knows no world better than that of the liberation struggle.” To players and supporters in the mid-seventies, West Indian cricket symbolised self-determination.


In 2023, however, the West Indies team failed to qualify for the ODI World Cup. They went from being among the strongest cricket teams in the world to a shell of their former self. It signalled a sombre chapter in the already lengthy and painful decline of West Indies cricket. The legendary team from the 70s, who clinched back-to-back crowns in 1975 and 1979, has faded from the collective memory of Caribbean society. Icons like Sobers, Lara, Richards, Marshall, Holding, and Ambrose are now more or less forgotten. Expecting a millennial to remember that era is tough, but a Gen-Z takes it to another level. When I asked a member of the Ashoka Cricket Team if he knew who Gary Sobers was, he replied, “That English pacer, no, bro?”


The key to this puzzle lies in understanding a simple fact. The West Indies is not a single country. While both Chris Gayle and Usain Bolt are Jamaicans, they represented different teams—Bolt in the Olympics for Jamaica, and Gayle in cricket for the West Indies. The West Indies are a group of fifteen English-speaking Caribbean nations and territories that carry a shared identity. The current West Indies cricket team represents several independent states and dependencies including Jamaica, Saint Lucia, Trinidad and Tobago and several other territories. Six million people living on these islands collectively is another factor in the Caribbean countries' decision to play as one entity. To put this in perspective, 34 million people live in Kerala, and 20 million people live in Sri Lanka. It is interesting that Caribbean nations field and have fielded individual teams for most other sports. For example, Jamaica qualified for the 1998 FIFA World Cup and has been the dominant country in athletics for the past 10 years. The West Indies as a concept in sport seems more or less confined to the cricketing world.


The decline of West Indies cricket is deeply tied to both internal issues and the changing priorities of Caribbean nations post-decolonization. Key among these factors is the withering of a unified West Indian identity—which was once held together by cricket—and the rise of individual nation-states that began to focus more on other sports and national achievements, particularly athletics in Jamaica. The West Indian island nation has produced world-class athletes like Usain Bolt and Shelly-Ann Fraser-Pryce. As Jamaica and other Caribbean nations directed their pride and funding into individual achievements in sports like athletics, the collective pride that once fueled West Indies cricket diminished. This shift in priorities led to less financial investment in cricket, with infrastructure and player development suffering as a result. This is highlighted by scholars and analysts who argue that post-independence, the shared West Indian identity began to fade, with cricket losing its symbolic power as a unifying force.


The West Indian cricket team can also be seen as a reflection of the broader decline in regional unity, exacerbated by economic struggles and the pressures of globalisation. As individual nations sought to carve out their identities on the world stage, cricket was no longer the prime vehicle for expressing West Indian pride. As noted by Beckles, West Indies cricket once represented a “liberation struggle,” but as this unifying cause diminished, so did the cohesion of the cricket team and its ability to compete at the highest levels​.


A large part of the decline also stems from poor leadership and management, particularly within Cricket West Indies (CWI). The CWI has been heavily criticised for its lack of strategic planning, inadequate player development programs, and an inability to retain top talent. For example, as noted in Barbados Today, one of the biggest failures of the CWI has been its inability to provide proper preparation for players before major international tours, such as the 2024 tour of England where players were grossly underprepared due to minimal training. England remained undefeated and the Windies hardly won a single session throughout this tour. This lack of investment in player development has left the West Indies Test team vulnerable and inconsistent, leading to a sharp decline in performance​. Further compounding the problem is the talent drain caused by the allure of more lucrative T20 leagues around the world. Players like Chris Gayle and Andre Russell, once central figures in West Indies cricket, have shifted their focus to these international leagues where the financial rewards far surpass those offered in regional competitions. This has weakened the core of the West Indies team and eroded the collective identity that once made the squad formidable. As a result, players have become more focused on individual success than on representing their nation or the region in Test and ODI formats​.


Interviews with West Indians show that this shift in player focus has been accompanied by a growing disinterest in cricket among younger generations. Many young West Indians now prefer sports like football or basketball, which they perceive as offering more opportunities and global exposure. Cricket—once a symbol of their unity and pride—has faded in relevance, especially in comparison to the global success of West Indian athletes in individual sports like track and field. This has only further diminished public support for the sport, contributing to the overall decline in funding and infrastructure. The combination of poor leadership, financial mismanagement, and the shift in both player and public priorities has resulted in a weakened West Indies cricket team that no longer commands the same respect or dominance it once did. 


There is still, however, a beacon of hope for West Indies cricket in the form of Shamar Joseph. Earlier this year, when the West Indies managed to draw a Test series 1-1 with Australia, Joseph was the name on everyone’s lips. I remember watching those final moments live and feeling an overwhelming sense of pride—almost as though the West Indies of old was roaring back. Joseph, battling with a broken toe, tore through the Australian batting lineup to pick up 7 wickets, bowling consistently at speeds of 140 kilometres per hour. Imagine that—running in for 12 overs with a broken toe when most people wouldn’t even be able to walk. What could possibly have kept him going?


Shamar Jospeh after picking up the final wicket at the Gabba (Jan 2024)


In the post-match interview, Joseph—often called ‘Baracara’s speed demon’ —gave us an answer. He said, “I wanted to keep pushing through the pain for my team and the people of the Caribbean.” It wasn’t just a personal victory; it was about something bigger—a flicker of the old West Indian spirit, a reminder of when cricket was more than just a sport for the Caribbean. Kraigg Brathwaite echoed this sentiment, talking about fighting for the West Indies, as if the echoes of past glories were starting to resound once more.


This resurgence of the old narrative brings hope. As I reflect on Joseph’s extraordinary effort, I can’t help but feel optimistic. In him, here’s a spark that reminds us that sometimes, the greatest victories are born out of the deepest struggles. West Indian cricket is currently facing its toughest barrage of bouncers. Whether they will weather the storm and emerge victorious will depend on their grit, passion, and, most importantly, patience. 


218 views0 comments

Related Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page