top of page

We the Students: Why Do Muslim Universities Need Students' Unions?

32 minutes ago
6 min read

As a first-year bachelor's student, walking past the Aligarh Muslim University Students' Union (AMUSU) building with a group of friends, I was struck by how silent it was, contrary to what I had learnt about its history, wherein there had once resided the arguments and anxieties of a generation that sometimes travelled far beyond the campus. At the time, I could not have imagined I would see thousands singing Tarana (the university’s official anthem) in that very space. The AMU administration suspended the AMUSU after the 2018–19 session, citing campus violence and indiscipline. There had been multiple protests for the union’s revival, including a major one in 2025 when students demanded elections alongside a rollback of a steep fee hike, and a student began an indefinite hunger strike. The administration promised to resolve the students’ demands, but that promise remained unkept. In October 2026, the union finally returned. 


The student struggle at AMU was not an isolated campus incident. No sooner had AMU seen its elections return, than the possibility of resuscitating minority students’ political autonomy reached Jamia Millia Islamia (JMI). Just as the formation of Jamia had come through the AMUSU, the struggle for the JMISU was ignited by the flames the AMUSU protests had blown. Subsequently, the Jamia administration agreed to union elections after two decades.


Muslim students at AMU, and in general, are often victims of hasty generalizations that treat them as a monolith. Students here arrive from across India, each belonging to different caste, class, gender, region and linguistic contexts. A large portion of the demographic populating AMU's hostels comes from regional pockets of Bihar and Eastern U.P., where the state has failed to provide basic infrastructure and quality schooling. The question of representation in AMUSU stems from the diversity of AMU's demographic and whether the union, as it has existed, has represented all those it claims to speak for. 


Ghulam Server writes: “OBC Muslims, Dalit-origin Muslims, Scheduled Tribe Muslims, women, and students from distant regions have reason to ask what a restored union would actually change for them.”


The 2026 AMUSU election results reflect this diversity. Nashra Naim was elected as the first woman Vice-President of the AMUSU in a ten-member cabinet comprising five women and five men. The cabinet also included a specially abled student and two students from Kerala, in an otherwise North-dominated body.


The Women's College sits about two kilometres from AMU's main campus, a constituent college of over 3,000 women students whose electoral relationship to the AMUSU has been contested for over a decade. The Women’s College voted in AMUSU elections only in 2010–11 and 2011–12, before the administration reverted to a separate union on grounds of geographical distance. The demands made by women students that emerged during the pre-election period—a 33% reservation for women students in the AMUSU, the inclusion of the three chairpersons of the Women’s College Student Union (WCSU) as ex-officio members, and dual voting rights for female students affiliated with the Women's College—stem from a national political context. Since 1951, only eighteen Muslim women have been elected to the Lok Sabha; in five of eighteen general elections, none secured a seat. The women students’ demands at AMU are a local form of Muslim women's political exclusion that affects the community, both on the axis of gender and religion, on a larger scale.


Articulation of student issues does not take place exclusively in the union hall—students discuss in the debating clubs, in reading circles, in the canteen, in the hostels. But these spaces have their own limitations, such as being too academic, exclusionary, informal, or episodic. They can carry the discourse, but they cannot act on it. The union is where the conversation acquires an institutional form capable of acting—and of articulating through structured dialogue— the collectively identified problems. Here, a Pasmanda student's grievance, a woman student's demand and a regional student's exclusion can be brought into the same room. The union has historically been the space where campus questions became community questions. Zakir Husain, who presided over the union's democratic turn in 1953 (when the constitution was amended to grant students the right to elect their own representatives) stated at the installation ceremony in 1954: "It seems to me that AMU Student's Union has a role of great significance to play in the development of India's national life." Laurence Gautier's archival records of the 1965 campaign state that the AMU Action Committee was "initially formed to protest against changes in internal quotas," and that its president, Basir Ahmad Khan, was "the former president of the Students' Union (1963–1964)." “Majlis leaders soon joined the Aligarh agitation. They transformed the university issue into a Muslim issue, of relevance to all Muslim citizens, much beyond the campus premises.” The campaign that began with students became, in the words of Maulana Abul Lais of Jamaat-e-Islami, "the problem of the entire Muslim community of India."


The importance of students' unions in Muslim universities, then, is that they are the condition of possibility for an intracommunity politics capable of institutional action and internal reformation. The union is the mechanism through which the minority's internal diversity translates its problems into a shared vocabulary and acts on them as issues of the whole community, beginning with the ordinary business of student life and extending, when it has earned the right, to matters beyond the university campus. 


The purpose of the union is, as a former AMUSU office-bearer put it, "to be able to think beyond one's immediate self, to think and act together, to find an expression of the self with others, among others, in others."


The local and national contexts give the union a dual function. The first is the ordinary function of any students’ union: betterment of student life through improvement of their living and learning conditions, and holding the administration accountable. However, since this is a minority institution, the union carries an additional possibility. It can serve as a civil-society platform where issues affecting Muslims as a community, and issues beyond the university campus, can be raised. But the second depends on the first. A union that cannot hold an administration accountable on the mundane conditions of student life is unlikely to be taken seriously when it speaks on a matter of national concern. The civil-society register is earned by doing the ordinary work well.


One may ask what it is that the union achieves which other forms of associational groups do not. In my view, the union's distinctiveness lies not merely in its institutional character but in its democratic nature. University-controlled committees can institutionalise solutions to student issues, but they do not make those solutions accountable to the demographic that produced them. Through the union's democratic character, the demographic holds decisions affecting students to account—through elections, the possibility of removal and the obligation of representatives to answer to those they represent. This is what distinguishes the union from the university cultural clubs, reading circles, and the administration's circulars and makes it an institution for an intracommunity politics that is genuinely of the community rather than merely about it.


For any ordinary citizen of the country, the suspension of the students' union is not a campus issue but a question about how minorities speak to themselves, to the nation, and how they are spoken to. “For the next generation of Muslim political leaders, the restoration of student unions should be understood as part of a wider question of democratic participation,” writes Adham Rafeek.


However, one must not romanticise potentiality to their whims. The same space can be used to exploit differences, to harden caste, region, and gender into weapons, and to raise polarising issues that benefit one faction while claiming to speak for the whole. Abdullah Azzam, a former AMUSU president, states this risk: "Power does the violence of simplification. It names us, reduces us to the places we come from, controls us in the name of hollowed traditions, and creates a small circle of reality that revolves only around ourselves. Back then it operated in the name of regionalism, a cheap call to tradition, and an ugly marking of space for fellow female students." The union also carries the potential to become what it seeks to confront and hold to account.


But for how long will the community refrain from confronting its own demons, which only makes the community legible to the administration, the state, and the broader society as a problem-object to be managed rather than as a political actor with its agency and internal complexities to be engaged with? Edited by Suryansh Jalan and Avika Mantri


Comments


bottom of page