top of page

The Mediocrity of NEET’s Meritocracy: From Dinner Parties to All India Ranks

10 minutes ago
6 min read

As news of Dharmendra Pradhan’s dutiful resignation spread online, Jantar Mantar erupted with celebratory exclamations and exchanges of victory. The Cockroach Janta Party (CJP) and its legion of youth, perhaps the most serious domestic crisis of Narendra Modi’s third term, got what they asked for. Replacing Dharmendra Pradhan was Pralhad Joshi, current minister of Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution, and New and Renewable Energy. Adding education to his roster, he seemed to embody the epitome of a jack of all trades, but master of none. As Sonam Wangchuk’s 26-day hunger strike ended, Pradhan’s term as Education Minister followed. The tear gas cleared, the lathis shook off the nails embedded in them, and the youth secured a win for the constitution. 


But what, exactly, did the Constitution win? 


The demands of the protesters were spread across three pillars: stop paper leaks, compensate families of students who passed away from suicide after the leaks, and do not administer punitive action against protesters. There was a pointed lack of discussion around the injustice of the system itself. None of these demands questions why a single exam on a single day decides the fate of lakhs of students, or why merit is determined by three decimal places on a rank list curated by factors beyond aptitude. Factors that, in the modern case, are modelled by social disparities. 


Pierre Bourdieu theorised that social inequality reproduces itself across generations without presenting as inequality. In ‘The Forms of Capital’, he defined capital as being economic, cultural, social, and symbolic. He argues that these four categories bleed into each other to reproduce inequality—wealth and assets provide access to knowledge and ‘taste’. This, in turn, gives way to higher social standing, eventually garnering recognition within privileged groups. The institutional structures backing NEET, JEE, CUET, and other public examinations follow this framework, but also theorisations closer to home. Satish Deshpande, in his paper ‘Exclusive Inequalities,’ argues that questions of merit and caste in tandem with higher education in India can be best answered through “exclusive inequalities” since, unlike primary education or healthcare, higher education is not a basic right but a deliberately selective sector. This means that the real question is not whether exclusion happens, but who designs its terms and who it habitually favours. The NEET was never a neutral network temporarily corrupted by paper leaks. It has always filtered students based on accumulated capital pumped into preparation instead of aptitude. In Bourdieu’s eyes, economic capital, converted into cultural capital, is laundered through a ‘merit’-based exam into social capital. A medical seat is viewed as a caste-blind credential that erases the unequal conditions that produced it. Kota’s money-hungry coaching economy, years of preparation, and capital that can absorb the loss of multiple failures are not incidental to NEET but a required part of its syllabus. Knowledge is stripped of its universality and laid bare, priced in rupees most households do not have. 


Deshpande’s research makes this concrete. Drawing on NSSO figures from a sample survey done in 1999-2000 for urban India, he shows that the upper-caste Hindu diaspora, roughly 37% of the urban population, accounted for close to two-thirds of the country's graduates and postgraduates: about 66% of medical graduates, 67% of engineering graduates, and 62% of graduates in agricultural sciences, against a share of barely a quarter to a third for OBCs and under 4% for Hindu SCs in most fields. He argues that this is not accidental dominance, but evidence of a system sustained by durable, self-reproducing gaps that keep it alive more than half a century after the constitutional ‘abolition’ of caste. Even within newer data, this pattern persists. NSS 68th round figures from 2011-12 show that upper-caste Hindus and non-Hindus made up approximately 41% of the urban population, but 59% of graduates and postgraduates. OBCs stood at a similar 41% of the population but made up 31% of the higher-education diaspora; SCs constituted 14%, with a share of only 7.5%; STs (3.4%) made up a dismal 2.5%. Though the two datasets are not strictly comparable, this pool further formalises the continued propagation of this education gap. More than a decade has passed, and yet education remains a function of privilege. 


This is further reflected in Deshpande’s distinction between “merit-discrimination” and “resource discrimination.” The examination-based segregation that higher education requires versus the unequal socio-economic endowments that determine who actually succeeds. The latter is often strategically overlooked by institutions. Paper leaks, then, fundamentally neutralise the privilege brought about by resource discrimination. The fury centres the negative return on investment in resources, since the time and money spent on preparation is wasted.

This ties into how quickly the protesters’ demands were acknowledged and met. A slap in the face of the farmers who besieged Delhi for a year to acquire anything, and a baton to the body for CAA-NRC protesters whose efforts were met with silence. This series of protests prompted action from our lethargic government within two months, resulting in the second administered resignation in Modi’s 12-year reign. This sudden loyalty to accountability is not a function of the paper leaks, but a reflection of who else, apart from the lower castes and classes, these paper leaks affect. Lokniti-CSDS post-poll data on the BJP's electorate offers a partial but telling frame here: while the party has spent the last decade deliberately broadening its coalition to include a large and growing share of non-Yadav OBC voters, its foundational, most consistently loyal base has remained the Hindu upper castes and the urban middle class. This is the same demographic most invested in the sanctity of an "unblemished" entrance exam. A cleft in that base is one this party cannot afford to ignore in the same way it has ignored the pleas of those from different social coalitions. 


A paper leak is an insult that bruises most when one has all the cards stacked in their favour. Panshul Bansal (NEET AIR 2), in an interview with NDTV regarding the protests, recites this sentiment through: “I thought, why should I go to the protest? Instead, I could be studying at home and improving my skills and improving my score.” He was studying under Allen, a private coaching institute that prepares students for entrance examinations. Lakhs put into coaching, a two-year runway, parents who can afford gap years, and an environment that allows for dedicated preparation form the foundation for an answer that is determined to overlook the plight of the underprivileged. Paper leaks hurt this privilege. They facilitate a photogenic rage that fills Jantar Mantar to the brim and is documented by media outlets across the board. Structural exclusion, by contrast, produces a duller, constant rage, with no single villain to depose. A rage that does not warrant even acknowledgement, let alone a resignation. UGC data submitted to a parliamentary panel also show a sharp rise in reported caste-discrimination complaints on campuses over the past five years, from 173 cases in 2019-20 to 378 in 2023-24. This rage refuses to boil over and flood the streets of Delhi, even when reservation comes with the subscript of caste discrimination.


Nestled within the NEET protests was another rage that spilled into Jantar Mantar on August 21st—a seething call for the abolition of reservation, better known as the Reservation Hatao Andolan. Started by NEET aspirant Harsh Dubey, the group mainly demanded the abolition of caste-based reservations, the elimination of caste-based identification, and a shift to economic criteria (even though a 10% reservation quota already exists for Economically Weaker Sections). Their demands uphold the idea that clearing NEET is a function of effort and merit alone; reservations challenge this idea. By replacing caste with income, they recast structural advantages as facets of individual circumstance, ignoring the caste capital that makes these circumstances (and subsequently, ranks) possible in the first place.  


And hence, the privileged class of consciousness rarely thinks of equality, because it rarely has to. The paper leak was a broken promise to the ‘elite’ at Kota: prepare hard enough, pay enough, and the rank list will reward you in proportion to your effort. That promise was always empty for the students the NSSO figures describe as structurally absent from higher education. For a paper leak to threaten the system’s fairness, a fair system has to exist in the first place. It was, as this piece has argued, an instrument of “exclusive inequality” by design. The demand for preventing paper leaks, rather than a conversation questioning the existence of this system, was a demand for a fairer hand in a structurally rigged game, not a demand to replace the existing deck of cards. It asks the state to protect the integrity of a ranking mechanism, but does not seek an explanation for why that mechanism has produced the same skewed outcome for decades, with or without a leak.


(Edited by Suryansh Jalan and Avika Mantri)

Comments


bottom of page