top of page

My Game in My Words: The Whistleblowers

1 day ago
4 min read

A Referee’s POV of Football at Ashoka


The ball races down the right flank. A defender closes in, a forward cuts inside, and suddenly there are three players on the ground. Half the field erupts. While someone is shouting for a foul, someone else is appealing for a penalty. The ball rolls out of play, but honestly, nobody is interested in that anymore. Instead, they turn towards me – twenty-two people, each with a slightly different idea of what just happened. I reach for my whistle.


Nobody claps when the whistle blows. It’s the very first thing you learn. When the whistle blows, only you know what the twenty-two don’t — that you’re right. But they’ve already decided that you’re the devil for the day.


In my years of refereeing intramural football, the one thing I’ve learnt is that I have the most honest seat in the house. I watch as players lie to the commentators, and as the spectators lie to themselves. I enjoy no such luxury.  A referee is the only person on the field who is expected to want neither side to win. 


Watching matches from a neutral perspective does something strange to you. Suddenly, you’re not watching the ball. Instead, you’re reading faces, something that says more than a pass or a goal ever could. Years of watching players show you how their psyche becomes an open book to you, all thanks to the ways in which they move. You see who flinches before the tackle; you see who’s prepared to argue even before you’ve reached for your pocket; you even see who apologises to an opponent when they think nobody’s looking. The most telling moment of the game is not when players gain control of the ball, but when they show grace and respect when you least expect them to. Once, I watched a player knock his opponent to the ground during a heated passage of play. His teammates were already appealing for the ball, but he was reaching out to help the other player up. Neither exchanged a word before they returned to compete against each other. Moments like these tell me considerably more about a player than anything they could do with the ball. While the scoreline tells you who wins, the faces of the players tell you who’s scared of losing.


You could assume that the worst part about this is the abuse. Though there is more than enough of that to go around, you’d be wrong. The worst part of this job takes place about ten seconds after you make a controversial call — when both teams look at you at once. You must choose. Either you explain, or you walk away. You know the rules, you know them like the back of your hand, and you know why you made a certain call. I remember what felt like an eternity explaining a decision to a player who had already decided I was wrong. I explained where the contact had occurred, what I had seen, and why I had made the right call. And listen he did, but he waited. Waited until I finished. Just to ask me the exact same question all over again. In the heat of the moment, players don’t look for explanations, they look for an admission, and while explaining your decisions might feel honest, it invites you to a fight you know you cannot win. Because when you’re one against an army of twenty-two, the odds are never going to be stacked in your favour.


What never fails to surprise me is how instinctively the players cheat. More often than not, it is improvised rather than planned. Nobody walks onto the field intending to dive. It takes place in a half-second of panic, when your body decides to fall before your mind agrees to it. I watch grown men negotiate with their own conscience out loud in real time, and lose.


One of the most common assumptions is that refereeing teaches you rules. To me, learning the rules is where you start. Refereeing is an unending journey of being tested and exposed, of learning to evaluate your mistakes, refine your judgement and improve your skills at every level. Between the numerous Laws of the Game tests, physical tests, physical assessments and on-field evaluations, you learn as much about yourself as you do about the game. But the most important thing you learn is never about yourself — it is about the gap between what people are willing to admit and what actually happened. The players edit the private replays of the matches in their mind in an attempt to make sense of it.


A match doesn’t always end when the whistle blows. You carry certain decisions home with you, like the ones you had only a fraction of a second to make. I remember a challenge near the penalty area where I had to decide, almost instinctively, whether the contact warranted a foul. I made my call, as always. The players protested, as always. The game moved on, as always. But later, I found myself replaying it in my head. Was I standing in the right place, at the right angle? Did I actually see the contact clearly, or was I just influenced by the way the player went down? A replay of the tackle in your mind makes you reconsider the angle you were standing at and wonder whether you were too quick to reach for your pocket, or too slow to blow your whistle.


You’re not a player. You don’t have the luxury of blaming the conditions, the opposition, or the pressure of the moment. You have to evaluate your own performance with the same objectivity you demand so righteously from everyone else. Sometimes you know you’ve got it right. Sometimes you know you could’ve done better. Regardless, you have to be prepared to come back the following week, sometimes the next morning itself, and make another twenty-two people unhappy.


I can’t call it a talent, so I just call it my job. I have the best seat in the stadium, but no one else wants it.


Prem Kujur (left) and Aftab Ashraf are the coaches of the Ashoka women's and men's football teams. Since the turn of the decade, they have led their teams to over thirty titles. Every year, they referee matches at the Batch Championships and the Ashoka Premier League. (Photo: Vivaan Bhupatrai/Caperture)
Prem Kujur (left) and Aftab Ashraf are the coaches of the Ashoka women's and men's football teams. Since the turn of the decade, they have led their teams to over thirty titles. Every year, they referee matches at the Batch Championships and the Ashoka Premier League. (Photo: Vivaan Bhupatrai/Caperture)

*


Edited by Aneek Chatterjee.

1 Comment


gaurimandradia
9 hours ago

You've made the loneliest job on the pitch sound like the best seat in the house, and after reading this, I'm convinced it is. Brilliant piece. I'd gladly watch you blow the whistle on anything, including bad writing, though you'd have nothing to flag here!

Like
bottom of page