Everything You Cannot See: Staging the Elizabeth Holmes Story
Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim's documentary You Can See Everything, released in October 2026 to widespread critical acclaim, opens not with its subject, Elizabeth Holmes, but with her husband, Billy. After a decade of public silence, it is not Holmes’ deep baritone that falls on expectant ears, but her husband’s flat, insistent voice. “What we as a unit have decided,” Billy begins, though he seems to have decided unilaterally. Holmes is pushed to the margins of the frame. She is at the far end of the nursery, cradling her baby, as the men talk business. Soon they leave her to it, and the camera shows only a suburban mother in her generic blue nursery, dressed in a loose shirt and jeans, entirely occupied with her child.
Gone is the visionary, the second coming of Steve Jobs. Gone, too, is the psychopathic monster who defrauded investors of millions. We have been primed for an encounter with one of the most notorious products of Silicon Valley, and instead we find an ordinary mother with a pushy husband. How do we reconcile this mundaneness with the turtleneck-wearing, magazine-posing avatar we know?
Holmes and Billy’s two babies are omnipresent in the first half of the documentary, filmed in the weeks before she enters prison. Their cries summon Holmes away from serious conversations. She bathes her children in the sink, reads to them; they sit in her lap or toddle about the expansive beach house she and her husband have rented in Del Mar, near San Diego. The house reportedly rents for $28,000 a month. The money presumably comes from Billy, who describes himself as “well-resourced’. Holmes, meanwhile, owes $452 million in restitution to her victims.
In the early scenes, sunlight floods the beach house through its tall windows, almost too obviously punctuating the title’s claim: you can see everything. Wherever Holmes and co. go, there goes the camera. And Nathan Fielder follows, the unlikely third to this remarkable couple. He hovers near door frames, squints at husband and wife from the shadows, and even looms over their marital bed. Yet he is hardly out of place. We quickly get used to the tidy little family circle: Holmes, her husband, their two kids, and Nathan Fielder. The blue and beige interiors give Holmes an air of doll-like fragility. She tilts her head as she listens to Fielder, her posture loose and inviting. She looks like a woman with nothing to hide.
She seems forever puzzled by how things went so wrong. She did the best she knew how. Theranos, it seems, was a horrible misunderstanding. When Holmes claimed its blood-testing machine “can run any test”, she meant that it might be able to, someday. But she also maintains that the machine worked. All this with the same wide-eyed, unblinking sincerity: “All I know is my truth.” And yet there is an eerie quality to the stillness of her face, the unvarying tone of her voice as she answers Fielder’s questions. She is rarely flustered by his prodding but cries often and freely, the first time barely ten minutes into the documentary. Later, she admits she would not let herself cry in front of others. Fielder responds with his characteristic deadpan: “Okay.”
The conversations between Holmes and Fielder are candid. He is a receptive listener, attentive to her feelings. Their faces are always inches apart, they seem to almost be exchanging breaths. Fielder is more often grave than comic, though he slyly pokes fun at her apparent obliviousness. He lets the camera linger through long pauses, unfinished sentences and her moments of confusion.
Billy and Fielder are a different story. Billy receives roughly as much screen time as Holmes. He emerges as a domineering, macho man, shown working out aggressively, or practising at shooting targets. He is also an avowed Charlie Kirk fan, positioning himself squarely as a traditional, politically conservative family man.
The crew even films him showering, full-frontal nudity and all. Again the documentary hammers home its point: you really can see everything. Yet later, Billy complains about the cameras' intrusion, petulantly claiming that they disrupt the Wi-Fi. The camera often pans to Holmes during Billy’s theatrics: her head is lowered as she though she does not hear him, or she speaks calmly on his behalf. Through the film’s strategic juxtaposition of the two, Fielder somehow makes Holmes the more reasonable person.
But one wonders how much of this was intentional. Fielder seems to despise Billy from the get-go, while his growing camaraderie with Holmes is equally obvious. In their interactions, and Fielder's careful editing, the documentary appears to take Holmes’ side. This strange Holmes-Billy-Fielder domesticity, however, has an expiry date. In the latter half of the documentary, Holmes enters federal prison. Her absence is stark: by the ninety-minute mark, I have grown so accustomed to her face that I find myself missing its warmth and peculiar magnetism.
Amanda Seyfried, who played Holmes in The Dropout, the 2022 dramatised Hulu miniseries about Theranos, is brought in as her substitute. Earlier, Fielder had filmed Holmes watching Seyfried perform her in The Dropout. Now Seyfried watches Holmes watching that performance, gaining inspiration for her return to the role. She recreates scenes from Fielder’s memory, moments when the camera was not pointed at them. She adopts the frozen face, the wide-eyed intensity, the compulsive, jerky nods: the consummate actress. But prolonged exposure to Holmes herself has spoiled the viewer. For the first time, immersion becomes difficult. It is not especially savvy to recognize that Holmes was also performing, as perhaps all documentary subjects do to varying degrees. Yet Holmes’ version persists as the ‘real deal’, while Seyfried’s faithful imitation makes one newly and uncomfortably conscious of artifice.
One of the scenes that Seyfried re-enacts introduces a crucial conflict. In an unfilmed meeting before shooting began, Billy had demanded a share of the documentary’s profits; an almost comically outrageous demand from a documentary subject, who anticipated, correctly, that the film would mint money. Holmes was once again absent from negotiations: in the re-enactment, Seyfried-as-Holmes steps away to attend to her motherly duties. Yet in recorded footage, Holmes claims that she has no “economic interest” in the documentary. The obvious conclusion, for Fielder, Seyfried, and us, the viewers, is that she knew nothing of Billy’s demand. But this hinges on taking Holmes, founder of Theranos, at her word.
Here is the film’s biggest twist: we realise that we cannot, in fact, see everything. By now, we have come to think of the camera as omnipresent. Suddenly, Fielder’s memories and Seyfried’s performance are all we have to go on, a pale shadow of the exhaustive footage we had grown accustomed to. Seyfried begins cross-questioning Fielder, and both he and the viewer must confront the question: have we, too, been duped by perhaps the supreme manipulator of the twenty-first century?
Fielder’s sympathy for Holmes seems almost like affection. He is personally entangled, compromised; his memories, too, are shaky. Their final conversation, in prison, is unrecorded and unknowable.
Is Billy doing her dirty work? His brashness, his aggression and instability are all on display. He is shown to the worst advantage, while Holmes appears warmer, softer, and more stable. Is he the convenient scapegoat, especially as he apparently believes that he is too smart to be fooled?
Memorably, during an interview with the couple at the beach house, Fielder takes Billy aside and asks if he ever worried that Holmes might have lied to him too. Billy dismisses the possibility. After all, what could she gain from deceiving him?
But Billy is wealthy, or at least comfortable, as the beach house testifies. He is also conventionally handsome, the father of Holmes’ cherubic, fresh-faced children. Together, they are the American suburban fantasy: an affluent white couple, two young kids, and a large house. In Trump’s America, where the white nuclear family is a powerful political ideal, they present an image of respectability, vastly preferable, in terms of optics, to her former relationship with the much older, Pakistani-born Sunny Balwani.
Motherhood is Holmes’ new project, one as far removed from Silicon Valley as possible. The pathos of a young mother shut away in prison, separated from her two babies is a more effective claim to our sympathy than any defence of her actions. It may be her ticket to public acceptability, her return to ordinary life.
A note at the end states that Billy ultimately relinquished his share of the documentary’s profits. Holmes’ knowledge of the deal remains an open question. Despite the extraordinary access Fielder is given—the wet dream of any documentary filmmaker—there is no final revelation. The camera has been pressed so close to Holmes’s face that we see the fine white fuzz on her cheeks, and yet we are no closer to knowing her.
There are many versions of her: the offbeat, trusting woman for whom Theranos was a horrible misunderstanding; an innocent woman subjected to a vicious media and judicial trial; the loving mother and devoted wife; a constant victim of controlling men. Or shall we consider the fraudster, the expert manipulator? A woman who has mastered the art of appearing perpetually duped. Is this authentic documentary version, too, simply a character she has created?
The documentary seems to suggest an answer. It ends with Fielder stating that Holmes truly loves her husband, and Seyfried-as-Holmes walking and playing with her two children. It ends as it began: Holmes as a mother and a wife. Holmes with a family. It is difficult to reconcile this woman with the conscienceless monster of the Theranos story.
But this version of Holmes is Amanda Seyfried, and the children are actors. The happy family is yet another reconstruction drawn from Fielder’s memory, imagination, or both. Is he offering Holmes a redemption story, or instead showing us how easily one can be created? The question is complicated by his own uncertainty about whether he has been taken in. But we, too, have spent over an hour in Holmes’ company, watching her cry, laugh, and hug her kids. She has looked into the camera, and into our eyes, insisting on her sincerity and good intentions.
Over the course of the documentary, Fielder has tracked Holmes’ inconsistencies, her lies and deflections, and the chilling disconnect between her account of herself and her role in running a company that endangered the health of its own patients. Even then, watching explicitly inauthentic images of domesticity, we may find ourselves moved and, at least for this viewer, teary. How much does all we know of Theranos, all we have learned of Holmes’ tactics, matter when the closing image proves so unexpectedly affecting? Does knowing we are being manipulated make us any less susceptible to falling into Holmes’ orbit?
It is these trailing questions, perhaps, that make the documentary a successful gamble for Holmes, whoever she may be.
(Edited by Aishani Misra and Maya Ribeiro.)




Comments